Sorry...I'm going to give it 4 stars, the thumb hole things are thin and twisty, so my husband thinks they won't work for sweaty hands and putting gloves on and off. The jacket is also a little short for what my husband wants, so great price and all it has to go back. I will also say there is nothing yellow about this jacket, as the title would have you believe. It's crayon red with brick red shoulders as pictured.This is a really good jacket. Warmer than I expected. I'm 5'11" about 160 lbs and the Large is good for me - not tight, not overly loose at all. Makes a little noise as these jackets can, but nothing that bothers me.If the liner was removable, this would be THE perfect jacket. As it is, I think it's as close as I'll get for my preferences. I did expect the Large to have a little more room to it, but it's not a problem.Jacket fits perfect. Very pleased with product. Better than expectedサイズもぴったりで、ホケットも多く、混入して良かった。